psychopathology imagined is very distant from how illnesses present in real people. the reason for this, i think, is that when we think of a depressed person, we think only about how they're depressed, and not at all about how they're a person, and after sitting and actually talking to someone with depression for 3 hours, you habituate to the sadness and the pain, and what emerges is just a core like anyone else would have. diagnosis is hard -- not just because of the therapist's humanity, but also because people contradict themselves, or misrepresent themselves, or just flat out lie
and of course there are the very human traps of wanting to diagnose people with the cool thing rather than the obvious thing (too much house!), or asking leading questions, or asking the wrong questions, and put that all together -- i guess what i'm trying to say is that what i'm doing now is hard, and hard in a different way from the academic work, because it's to do with people, who are messy, and because i often feel like i don't really know what i'm doing, and because we don't get any answers once our patients get sent away back to their primary therapists. so what you have instead is that those with high self-esteem pat themselves on the backs, and the ones with low self-esteem keep second-guessing themselves even after the report has been turned in and the patient gone forever.
i think i'm somewhere in the middle, reared on ten-year series where you get to go to the back of the book for the answers, far enough along in the process to realize the blatant stupidity of that. unlearning the lessons of childhood is a long journey; fortunately, it's one i've been given the chance to make.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Pages

Contributors
- The Corgi of Mystery
- 1980: Born. 1989: Sudden affliction of self-awareness. Things downhill ever since.
My Blog List
-
-
-
Monday, December 19, 20168 years ago
-
the way around is through8 years ago
-
Goodbye, Flying Inkpot10 years ago
-
-
-
The Glorious Unfolding11 years ago
-
On Friendship (Part II)14 years ago
-
-
-
-
Quote of the Week
--
Blog Archive
-
▼
2007
(198)
-
▼
November
(16)
- From Wheels Of Fortune in The New Yorker, Nov 26, ...
- psychopathology imagined is very distant from how ...
- the mcroyale-with-cheese effect
- the leaves fell last night, all at once, accumulat...
- char kway teow (ii)
- also by steven weinberg
- char kway teow (i)
- the heat in our house is really weird; it seems to...
- to tell someone you think they have alzheimer's di...
- sfn (v)
- sfn (iv) -- neuroethics
- sfn (iii)
- sfn 2007(ii)
- sfn 2007
- From The Omnivore's Dilemma, Michael Pollan:... Br...
- merely players
-
▼
November
(16)
1 comment:
haha well said. i'm still trying to undo the ten-year series effect. an analogous syndrome might be the google effect - 'it must be somewhere out there if i search hard enough'.
adam
Post a Comment